Susan
A recent writing exercise, based around some thoughts on using event-specific labels outside of their original context.
I just got used to saying “I met my wife on a train,” and now I have to say “I met my ex-wife on a train.” Of course it was a silly thing to say anyway. I didn’t meet my wife on a train, I met a lovely stranger named Susan Harris, and 13 hours later (4 hours after I forgot to get off at my stop) the train let us out in Berkeley. Then I took my friend to have a few drinks, and woke up the next morning with my lover. I met my wife in a chapel, 6 months later. At some point after that the girl from the train went back to Berkeley, and Mrs. Susan Green stayed behind. I didn’t love her the way I loved Susan Harris, and she noticed. She knew I was talking to a Susan that wasn’t there, and the Susan that I made love to was not the same Susan in my bed.
So I guess it only makes sense that the papers I’m supposed to sign don’t ask for anything. Because once I sign them she’ll be Susan Harris again, and Susan Harris already has everything I could possibly have given her. But I’ve been me this entire time. Been me as hard as I could, when it took every once of effort not to be a lie to Susan Green. And when I sign I won’t be me anymore, now or ever again. And I won’t have to say that I met my ex-wife on a train, because the person that met Susan Harris on a train to Berkeley won’t be around to make the statement true. It’ll just be me, whoever that is.
I’m probably supposed to think it’s strange that another person could ravage your life this way, make you feel like neither of you ever existed, and at the same time be the only thought you can’t push out of your mind. And I should find it strange to think she really is different now and I’m not, that she will become someone different once again, perhaps several times more. After all, it’s just one woman. But it all makes perfect sense to me.
Everyone changes, but somehow she managed to do it so quickly. She stopped staying up late with me, stopped singing and painting, stopped ripping seams and losing buttons to get to the skin underneath. Even her hair and her clothes changed… without warning. After we married she stopped saying that we met on a train, told friends she had never even been to Berkeley, like she wanted to suffocate Susan Harris, wipe her out altogether.
I should have done the same, but I held on to Susan Harris so tightly. I tried to hear her humming in the shower or catch her glance across the breakfast table. But she was never there. Only Mrs. Green. Then I started following my wife to work and when she visited friends, hoping that maybe she became my Susan when she left, hoping that if I saw a glimpse then I could bring her back. But I never saw a thing. Even her eyes seemed different.
I don’t blame Susan Green for wanting to leave. How could she stay? In the end she even thought I might be losing my mind, and I fear that I am. My mind was the first thing Susan Harris took, and she wasn’t giving it back. Even the papers I have to sign say that I barely have the competence to do so, that I can’t be trusted with my safety, or Susan’s. I would argue and say that Susan Harris will always be safe with me, but even the papers know that Susan Harris isn’t here anymore. She’s back in Berkeley, where she’s always been.